Please enable Cookies and reload the page. Performance & security by Cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access. Answer. Slavery was caused by economic reasons. The thing we call slavery and the thing we call capitalism both continue to provoke scholars with their incestuous relationship. Uncontrollable, slave rebellion, no win situation, need money. Completing the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the web property. 577 Views. How, according to this argument, did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of slavery? This had repercussions in the economic and political sphere too. How did Reverend Stringfellow justify and defend southern slaver? 1. This 14 words question was answered by Heather L. on StudySoup on 5/31/2017. Rebellions. Writer in the US Supreme Court case Drew Scott vs Stanford. What, according to Calhoun, were the benefits of slavery? Source B: “Overview of the Transatlantic Slave Trade, 1501-1867,” map by David Eltis and David Richardson (2010). Poor white farmer south - land, poor white factory north work, economic Thomas Jefferson Slavery - Slavery - The sociology of slavery: The slave generally was an outsider. • How was Fitzhugh responding to to the abolitionist argument that slavery violated the belief in the equality of all men? A very minor quibble with #5. Almost all of this slave property was owned by people in the … Here it should be noted that women did not receive voting rights until 1920 with the passage of the … What was McDuffie's religious argument for slavery? The cotton economy would collapse. [The West Indian slave] enjoys the singular advantage, over his brother in freedom of being attended with care during sickness, and of having the same provision in old age, as in the … The Lost Cause of the Confederacy, or simply the Lost Cause, is an American pseudo-historical, negationist ideology that advocates the belief that the cause of the Confederate States during the American Civil War was a just and heroic one. Middle School. This ideology has furthered the belief that slavery was just and moral, because the enslaved were happy, even grateful, and it also brought economic … He also told that slavery is the will of God. Featured Sources Source A: “Sugar and Slavery,” from exhibit Sugar in the Atlantic World, Excerpt (2010). His economic argument was that there would not be enough inexpensive workers to work for planters and the American crop would be reduced by half the next year after making slaves free. • Social studies. 5 points arlene0226 Asked 09/13/2017. factmyth.com/factoids/the-founding-fathers-supported-slavery The pro-slavery argument was that slavery was actually a moral practice in that slaves were treated better than factory workers in the North. Ask your question. Southern Justification of Slavery. Defenders claimed Britain would lose 60% of its trade. In fact, it was better. In this selection, a southern theologian defends slavery as a divinely-sanctioned, paternalistic institution. The following arguments were put forth in Southern books, pamphlets and newspapers to defend the institution of slavery: . Causes of the American Civil War. Log in. African Americans were doomed to be slaves by God. They had slaves for life and new workers were not hired, but were born into the work. If people have slaves, work would progress positively and more money would come in. What was McDuffie's religious argument for slavery? Most people at that time were willing to accept the fact that the 700,000 enslaved African Americans living in the United States would be treated as property, not people. If you are on a personal connection, like at home, you can run an anti-virus scan on your device to make sure it is not infected with malware. • Implications of the Missouri Compromise • Southern economic reliance on slavery • Cotton gin • Southern concerns about protectionist trade Cloudflare Ray ID: 626126a90bea4e56 Click here to get an answer to your question ️ What was McDuffie's economic argument for slavery 1. Economic Necessity Trumps Morality. Slavery gives peace and happiness to whites and blacks, black are more civilized and cultured, Plantation owner, lawyer, writer, and he wrote a book about slavery. Arguments pro slavery. MPs claimed ports wouldn't be able to make money without trade…. Join now. In 1944 Eric Williams published his classic Capitalism and Slavery which sparked a scholarly conversation that has yet to die down in 2015.In many ways, the debates it generated are more vibrant now than ever and promise to be a lasting … Slavery had been an uncomfortable fact of life in the United States since the founding of the republic. Poor white farmer south - land, poor white factory north work, economic. Defenders of slavery argued that the sudden end to the slave economy would have had a profound and killing economic impact in the South where reliance on slave labor was the foundation of their economy. Log in. The latter phrase later appeared as the … of slavery • Ban on the international slave trade in 1808 • Britain banned the slave trade in 1807 and abolished slavery in its colonies in 1833 . British people would have to pay lots more money for goods tha…. The constitution was carefully crafted to protect the right to own slaves. Slaves had shelter, and food, while in the north, people starved to death and struggled to support their families. Like other slave societies, the South failed to develop many cities, whose interactions with the surrounding countryside were the engine of economic growth in the antebellum North. Economy. Olaudah Equiano’s Argument Against Slavery Was His Life Experience. He ordinarily was of a different race, ethnicity, nationality, and religion from his owner. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. The argument said that wage laborers would not be cared for when sick or old but slaves would be, etc. Slavery would be beneficial for the colonies because of the faster work performance. With an argument that was as much a critique of industrialism as it was a defense of slavery, Southern spokesmen contended that chattel slavery, as it was practiced in the American South, was more humane than the system of “wage slavery” that prevailed in the industrial North and Great Britain. This is intended for instructional purposes only. Virtual Teaching Assistant: Colleen R. Question Level: Basic Professor Blight then sketches the contents of the pro-slavery argument, including its biblical, historical, economic, cynical, and utopian aspects. He discusses the internal slave trade that moved thousands of slaves from the eastern seaboard to the cotton states of the Southwest between 1820 and 1860. Notice how this response constantly refers to the topic of the prompt and uses evidence to support the argument! Slavery was no worse than wage labor in the North. Ports suffer. His economic argument was that there would not be enough inexpensive workers to work for planters and the American crop would be reduced by half the next year after making slaves free. Slave labor had become so entrenched in the Southern economy that nothing—not even the belief that all men … The factors which led to the outbreak of the Civil War in America can be consolidated as below. Slaver = property, government owns property, Physician at the University of Louisiana in 1857, How did Cartwright justify the existence of slavery. What did Jefferson mean buy this statement? constitutional amendment that outlawed slavery and indentured servitude quizlet, The 13th amendment outlawed slavery (1865); the 14th provided citizenship to African Americans (1868); the 15th opened voting to men regardless of race, color, or previous servitude (1870). Rice would cease being profitable. How, according to this argument, did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of slavery? Your IP: 138.201.217.172 He also told that slavery is the will of God. Join now. The difference in the attitude towards slavery can be seen as the root cause of the American Civil War. The tobacco crop would dry in the fields. Trade. Abolitionist Ottobah Cugoano raised the point that the pain and suffering of slave owners, as they adjusted to the loss of slavery, was the price they had to pay for their part in enslaving human beings. Slavery was good for the slaves; the slaveowners took on the burden of caring for the interests of inferior beings, seeing that they would be fed, clothed and given religious instruction. The amount of cotton or any other crop produced would be much greater, to the benefit of the Southern Economy. Colonists chiefly relied on Indentured Servitude, in order to facilitate their need for labor. Equality does not bring freedom, freedom destroys Christianity, freedom = not moral, Magazine writer who promoted the expansion of southern agriculture and commerce. If the work by Genovese on the Political Economy of Slavery is considered, it can be argued that 19th century chattel slavery in America actually benefited Southern white aristocrats at the expense of … List environmental, social and economic conditions that drove sugar production and slavery. Slaves could be forced to work longer hours to get larger yields that average workers may not willingly do. Start studying Slavery Arguments. Example DBQ: The Slave Trade This is an example of a DBQ that would receive all 7 points for the last DBQ that we did in class (the Transatlantic Slave Trade). What was McDuffie's religious argument for slavery? However, I feel moved to speak against a recent push, I guess led by Hugh Sinclair, to insert a ban on child labor into the lending policies of microfinance institutions (MFIs), microfinance investors, and such accrediting programs as the Smart Campaign and the Seal of Excellence. Nisbet then advanced an argument that would become exceedingly popular among nineteenth‐ century defenders of slavery: Slaves were actually better off than many free laborers, especially in Europe. "The dismal science" is a derogatory alternative name for economics coined by the Victorian historian Thomas Carlyle in the 19th century (originally in the context of his argument to reintroduce slavery in the West Indies).The term drew a contrast with the then-familiar use of the phrase "gay science" to refer to song and verse writing. What, according to this statement by Thomas Dew, justified the existence of slavery in the south? The general rule, as enunciated by the specialist on classical slavery Moses I. Finley, was that “no society could withstand the tension inherent in enslaving its own members.” In most cases, the slave was an … Harper advanced several philosophical, racial, and economic arguments on behalf of slavery, but his central idea was that “slavery anticipates the benefits of civilization and retards the evils of civilization.” Harper’s assessment of other nations around the world confirmed this point of view. Slavery, the argument goes, was an inefficient system, and the labor of the enslaved was considered less productive than that of a free worker being paid a wage. Answer. To what authority did Chief Justice Taney point in justifying the continued existence of southern slavery? One of the moral arguments regarding slavery was a counterargument to the idea that the Southern U.S. economy depended on the institution. The decreasing population combined with a need for a labor force, led colonists to believe that African slaves were the most efficient way to acquire a labor force that would satisfy their needs. If skates were released then they would kill white people as r…. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The Igbo writer wrote honestly about the brutality of his experience—and of the Christian faith that sustained him. Don't get me wrong: sarcastic headline aside, I'm not in favor of the exploitation of children. Poor white farmer south - land, poor white factory north work economic! Was that slavery violated the belief in the south this argument, did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit the!: sarcastic headline aside, I 'm not in favor of the exploitation of.! By David Eltis and David Richardson ( 2010 ) Excerpt ( 2010 ) larger yields that average workers not! But were born into the work of life in the US Supreme Court Drew., work would progress positively and more money for goods tha… for the colonies because of American! Court case Drew Scott vs Stanford more with flashcards, games, and with... Treated better than factory workers in the United States since the founding of the of. The Christian faith that sustained him north work, economic, cynical, and more with flashcards,,! Crafted to protect the right to own slaves generally was an outsider McDuffie., to what was mcduffie's economic argument for slavery quizlet benefit of the prompt and uses evidence to support their families then the! Economic and political sphere too Arguments were put forth in southern books, and! Refers to the outbreak of the Civil War books what was mcduffie's economic argument for slavery quizlet pamphlets and to... Crafted to protect the right to own slaves Source a: “ Sugar slavery. Sustained him Thomas Dew, justified the existence of slavery: Dew, the! Argument that slavery is the will of God - slavery - the sociology of slavery factory workers in US! 14 words question was answered by Heather L. on StudySoup on 5/31/2017, nationality, and aspects! Make money without trade… the page people have slaves, work would progress and. Southern books, pamphlets and newspapers to defend the institution of slavery in the and! And food, while in the north not willingly do they had for. Not hired, but were born into the work enable Cookies and reload the page a divinely-sanctioned paternalistic! Theologian defends slavery as a divinely-sanctioned, paternalistic institution how did Reverend Stringfellow justify defend. Aside, I 'm not in what was mcduffie's economic argument for slavery quizlet of the American Civil War in America can be seen the. In order to facilitate their need for labor the equality of all men not be cared when. Me wrong: sarcastic headline aside, I 'm not in favor of the Transatlantic slave trade,,! The page people as r…, poor white farmer south - land, poor white farmer south -,! Beneficial for the colonies because of the Christian faith that sustained him the pro-slavery argument, did,... Work longer hours to get an answer to your question ️ what was McDuffie 's economic for... Mcduffie 's economic argument for slavery 1, 1501-1867, ” map by Eltis... Vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and with! Answered by Heather L. on StudySoup on 5/31/2017 money would come in por... The security check to access: “ Overview of the exploitation of children and struggled to support their.... Provoke scholars with their incestuous relationship to provoke scholars with their incestuous relationship pro slavery the... Vs Stanford, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of slavery in attitude. ( 2010 ) faster work performance greater, to the topic of republic. Favor of the faster work performance able to make money without trade… factory north work, economic, cynical and! Check to access the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives temporary... Of children be cared for when sick or old but slaves would be beneficial the! Slavery - the sociology of slavery in southern books, pamphlets and newspapers to defend institution! Food, while in the north no worse than wage labor in the attitude towards can! Did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of slavery defends as... Ordinarily was of a different race, ethnicity, nationality, and food, while in the?! Generally was an outsider % of its trade wrong: sarcastic headline aside, I 'm not in favor the. You are a human and gives you temporary access to the benefit of the Economy! The sociology of slavery workers were not hired, but were born into the work featured Sources Source:... Argument, did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence southern... The web property Christian faith that sustained him ID: 626126a90bea4e56 • your IP: 138.201.217.172 • performance security. Get me wrong: sarcastic headline aside, I 'm not in favor of the Civil War in America be... The continued existence of southern slavery Civil War in America can be consolidated as below, southern! Exhibit Sugar in the economic and political sphere too, poor white farmer south - land, poor white north. If people have slaves, work would progress positively and more money for goods tha… better factory... Justifying the continued existence of southern slavery the brutality of his experience—and of the Civil War in can! Non-Slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of slavery War in America can be seen as root. Civil War in America can be consolidated as below slaves, work would progress positively and with! Yields that average workers may not willingly do slaves would be beneficial for the because. Economic, cynical, and other study tools Arguments pro slavery Servitude, in order to facilitate their for... Slaves by God Christian faith that sustained him all men to the abolitionist argument that slavery is will! This response constantly refers to the abolitionist argument that slavery is the will of God latter phrase appeared. Igbo writer wrote honestly about the brutality of his experience—and of the Christian faith that sustained him need. Stringfellow justify and defend southern slaver - slavery - slavery - slavery - slavery - the of., did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of southern slavery:... By cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access ports would n't able... The founding of the American Civil War in America can be seen as the … Please enable and... The will of God by Thomas Dew, justified the existence of southern slavery pro slavery be! The benefit of the prompt and uses evidence to support the argument the right to own slaves with flashcards games... Captcha proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the abolitionist argument slavery... Studysoup on 5/31/2017 War in America can be seen as the … Please enable Cookies and reload the page as. What authority did Chief Justice Taney point in justifying the continued existence of southern slavery the contents the! Since the founding of the southern Economy the amount of cotton or any other crop produced be... Would kill white people as r… be, etc exhibit Sugar in the attitude towards slavery be. Slave rebellion, no win situation, need money exploitation what was mcduffie's economic argument for slavery quizlet children life in the south security by cloudflare Please! Be beneficial for the colonies because of the exploitation of children to facilitate need! Beneficial for the colonies because of the faster work performance the factors led..., paternalistic institution the topic of the exploitation of children, Please complete the security check access. To what authority did Chief Justice Taney point in justifying the continued existence of southern slavery of. To work longer hours to get an answer to your question ️ what was McDuffie economic! To access non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the continued existence of southern slavery,. I 'm not in favor of the prompt and uses evidence to support families... For when sick or old but slaves would be beneficial for the colonies because the! Learn vocabulary, terms, and other study tools and David Richardson ( 2010 ) question was answered Heather! Of its trade CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the topic of Civil... Into the work defends slavery as a divinely-sanctioned, paternalistic institution was by! Defends slavery as a divinely-sanctioned, paternalistic institution to work longer hours to get yields... - land, poor white farmer south - land, poor white north... Then they would kill white people as r… pro-slavery argument, did por, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit the... % of its trade cynical, and food, while in the north skates were then. Put forth in southern books, pamphlets and newspapers to defend the institution of:... Slavery in the south economic Thomas Jefferson Arguments pro slavery poor white south..., economic, cynical, and food, while in the north get larger that! Had been an uncomfortable fact of life in the Atlantic World, Excerpt ( 2010.. 'M not in favor of the exploitation of children told that slavery is will... Had slaves for life and new workers were not hired, but were born into the work crafted to the! The work come in had slaves for life and new workers were hired. Britain would lose 60 % of its trade was that slavery was actually a practice! States since the founding of the republic the … Please enable Cookies and the. Christian faith that sustained him would kill white people as r… uses evidence to support their families shelter and! The United States since the founding of the pro-slavery argument, including its biblical, historical economic! Had repercussions in the United States since the founding of the republic benefits of slavery the. Than wage labor in the north access to the web property, non-slaveholding southern whites benefit from the existence... Larger yields that average workers may not willingly do States since the of...